Fundamentalist Christians don’t have a lot of nice things to say about Catholics. According to them, we know nothing of the Bible, create false doctrines, are wolves in sheep’s clothing while being the embodiment of whore of Babylon, run a secret society in league with the Free Masons and Satanists, and of course, we’re idolaters.

Pretty impressive résumé if you ask me.

Sadly, we cannot take credit for any of these things as they live more in the imaginations and misconceptions of our literalist and pre-critical brothers and sisters in Christ. They are based on misinformation, fear, and downright disdain, rather than the facts, and serve to galvanize their own people against a common enemy.

And it’s effective. Surely, it is. When you can look to a popular and successful entity and explain away their success by undermining their credibility, one can feel much better about their own efforts. When there is someone to blame for the problems of the world (especially when that someone is incredibly influential and ever-present) responsibility for such evil is greatly lessoned. What can we really do when they are doing so much evil?

Of course, we are not their enemy. As brothers and sister in Christ, we may have a different approach to some things, but we are still one in baptism and so one in the Lord. We are not their enemy.

In this week’s Catholicism in Focus, I look at one of the greatest points of conflict between fundamentalists and Catholics, the use of images in worship. Largely the result of major misconceptions, I hope to shed light on what we really believe in order to show our critics that we are on the same team, that this is not the first time we have faced this issue, and the Church has answered it clearly.

For more information on the topic of supposed idolatry in Christianity, the name of this criticism is called “Iconoclasm” and it was addressed in the Second Ecumenical Council of Nicaea in 787.

When the world looks at my life, they see a crazy person. Poverty, chastity, obedience. Wearing medieval clothing. Spending time with people no one deems useful or attractive.

Oh, and giving away my books for free and traveling the country to preach. That too.

Frankly, I can’t imagine doing anything else. When you’ve been loved by God, nothing else makes sense but being a little crazy.

Click here to listen

If you haven’t seen the Netflix original Two Popes, Br. Tito and I highly recommend it. That is, with an important caveat: it’s a complete work of fiction. While, yes, there are in fact two living men who at one point were popes, and yes, much of the movie is based on true events, the entire premise is fictional. The movie centers around two encounters—Cardinal Bergoglio meeting Pope Benedict XVI at Castle Gandolfo to discuss Bergoglio’s retirement, and the two meeting later to share confessions with one another—that never happened! There is no evidence that these conversations ever took place. (Even the name is misleading! There are not two popes. We have one pope, and that is all. Benedict XVI, while pope at one point, is a retired theologian with no apostolic authority to teach.)

And yet… we still recommend the movie. Despite its historical inaccuracies, despite its mind-numbing oversimplifications, despite its frustrating portrayals at times… it is a beautiful movie with powerful themes.

As a work of non-fiction, it is a hot mess. As a work of fiction, it is one of the best examples of faith, doubt, vocation, reconciliation, and dialogue that I’ve seen in cinema. And from a secular studio for a secular audience, no less!

According to the Catechism of the Catholic Church, sin is “an offense against reason, truth, and right conscience; it is failure in genuine love for God and neighbor caused by a perverse attachment to certain goods. It wounds the nature of man and injures human solidarity. It has been defined as ‘an utterance, a deed, or a desire contrary to the eternal law.'”

And as far as definitions go, that’s great, very clear. Except…

All are sins the same? When is something a sin and when is it not? Are there exceptions? Are we always responsible for sin?

The fact of the matter is that sin is a very murky subject, filled with ambiguity and requiring much critical thought. In this video, I look at what the Church says about the morality of human acts in article 4 of the Catechism’s chapter on the Dignity of the Human Person. According to the Church, there are actually three factors that go into the evaluation of morality: object, intention, and circumstances.

Have you ever looked around and wondered what God’s plan for you was? It can seem like a daunting question to answer. Of all the millions of things to do in the world, how am I going to figure this out?

Sometimes, the answer is simpler than we think. In this week’s video, I suggest a three-part process to find one’s calling. Ask yourself these three questions, and you’ll be on your way to growing closing to God, and what God wants for you!