Don’t Become a Priest

This is not click bait. In this video, I legitimately discourage people from becoming priests.

Why? Because some people shouldn’t become priests.

In the midst of a priest crisis sweeping much of the world, the idea of discouraging people from becoming priests might sound rather strange, but let me remind you that quantity is not the same as quality. In my years of formation, I attended two different seminaries, went on plenty of inter-community retreats, engaged with seminarians from all around the world. In that time, I met some truly remarkable people who inspired me to be a better priest. I also met some men that sent shivers down my back.

It should not surprise you that there are men in seminary who want to be a priest for the wrong reasons; there are men in seminaries who will grow up to be horrible pastors, scattering the flock and causing damage to people’s faith. While I make no claims as to how prevalent these issues are, I can ensure you that there are seminarians who do not want to work, who have an inflated sense of self, who believe that they are a gift to the Church and so should be treated like princes, who are more concerned with appearances and perks than they are with prayer and penance.

This will not do.

The priesthood is not a right. Being ordained is not something anyone deserves. Just because certain areas might be desperate for priests does not mean that anyone will do. In fact, the existence of lazy, egotistical, princes in rectories and seminaries might actually do more harm turning people away from the Church than the sacraments will attract. I suspect that having only 10 holy and hardworking men dedicated to the mission of Christ would do more to inspire a nation and rebuild the Church than 1000 men in it for the wrong reasons.

It’s not about the numbers. We can never get caught up in that. Quantity does not replace quality. What we need are not more priests, but better ones. Dedicated ones. Holy ones.

If that’s not what you’re looking for, then as my professor told us, “We don’t need you.” It might sound harsh, but it’s the truth. We need more than warm bodies.

We need pastors. Are you willing to lay down your life for others? Are you willing to give up your own time, comfort, reputation, opinions, and authority in order to serve the people of God? If so, you are exactly what the Church needs.

6 Comments on “Don’t Become a Priest

  1. Good Morning Laura, Sharing with you Casey’s post from yesterday, What a big true, I love it. See you at 5 pm, gave a great day Pilar 😘🙏

    Sent from my iPad Pili


  2. A big true Fr.Casey ,is important always quality no quantity I love it. Lots of blessings from NY. Pilar

    Sent from my iPad Pili


  3. Father Casey, Sounds neat to be able to address you with that title
    This latest post is wild. Over the years I have known the “princes’ you address,.
    You are responsible for my wanting to return to the Church. (please do not get a big head”

    Thank you

  4. I get the point and it’s quite wise. We need more quality than quantity. We have to pray for our priest for them to be real saint priests as Jesus deserves.

  5. I was recently in a vocational awareness weekend and one of the things that turn me down was what you mention here. Im no one to judge but i could notice the lack of humility in some priests. That’s not really what I’m looking for. I might be an idealist. But for now I will try to serve God as I can. I still believe in my faith but I don’t get the point of becoming a priest to get the message of God to others.
    I will keep praying to discern my further decisions anyway.

  6. This is why the church needs to change to have more Catholics and more vocations.

%d bloggers like this: