The Danger of Christian Apologetics

When I went to college, I was really excited about my faith. I was proud to be a Catholic and I wanted other people to know about it. There was only one problem: I knew very little about my faith. (Small detail…) Living in South Carolina at the time—a place with fewer Catholics than those who do not like Catholics—I found my faith challenged on a regular basis.

“Why do Catholics worship Mary?”

“Catholics aren’t real Christians.”

“The Pope is a made up power ploy.”

“That’s not in the Bible.”

I needed to learn about my faith. I needed to learn how to defend my faith. Luckily for me, our Church has a long history of defending itself from outside attacks, dating all the way back to the second century with people like Justin Martyr. And even though things didn’t exactly work out for him (…) his work was instrumental in keeping the faith alive at a time when attacks were not only verbal but also violent. Rather than responding with violence, Apologists, as they were called, defended the faith with intellect and charity, allowing the faith that they believed in to speak for itself and stand up against criticism.

These “apologies” continue today, although in varied forms. In its best form—that which I encountered in college—truth and charity work together, sharing what we know to be accurate about our faith without compromising on the life we live, engaging our enemies while also loving them. This form of apologetics defends without being defensive, knowing that if something is true it will stand up to questioning, and more importantly, recognizing that sometimes the most powerful argument we have is not with our mouths or intellect but with the way we treat others.

Unfortunately, this is not the only form of apologetics known to our Church. Sometimes, as sad as it sounds, we find those in the Church that choose truth or charity, picking one without the other. Armed with the truth of our faith, they treat those who do not believe as we do as enemies, dangerous individuals that need to be defeated at all cost. While the content of their speech is (often) accurate, the speech itself fails to live up to the expectations of the Gospel; as we say, what you say is not as important as how we say it, and sometimes apologetics undermines its truth by saying it with hate.

But this is not the only problem we need to be aware of with modern apologetics, which is the subject of this week’s video.

4 Comments on “The Danger of Christian Apologetics

  1. I was not invited to a concert workers wedding because I was catholic and worshipped Mary
    I didn’t know how to respond so I asked my priest
    He said when someone says that to you answer with “so”
    Easily done

  2. The devices of torture used during the inquisition were quite effective methods of convincing others about the true faith.How about the rack: the rack, also called the potro or escalera, is one of the most widely known torture method from the Spanish Inquisition. The victim was tied down to a plank of wood while a crank was turned, pulling all four limbs away from the body.

    In one extreme case, a young man was being tortured on the rack and a fire was lit underneath him to add to his suffering. His limbs were pulled so hard that they were ripped from his body, and the deluge of blood put out the fire. Now that’s pretty metal.

  3. I love your authenticity and humor! You are an incredible teacher. I am not Catholic, and I love learning about the Church from your posts and videos 🙂 Thank you for sharing your spiritual journey!

  4. It seems to me that the damage of apologetics doesn’t come from the practice of encouraging critical thought, but rather comes from our own misapplication though. Apologetics done rightly, of which we can debate what “rightly” means, seems to me a good thing.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: