The following is a reflection on this week’s readings, the 24th Sunday of Ordinary Time, year C.
Have you ever stolen something, lied to your parents, called someone a hurtful name, done something hurtful to yourself, or anything else you regretted enough to had to go to confession?
If so, have you ever been smote by God’s wrath, hit by a lightning bolt from heaven, or dropped dead immediately after doing something wrong? Probably not.
Or, after having done something wrong, something you regretted, did you later have an experience of God, a powerful prayer, a feeling of relief, or anything that made you know that God was still with you, that he had not abandoned you? My guess is that the latter experience is a bit more common…
You see, on the one hand, our God is a God of justice. He set a way that his people were to live and told them that if they follow it they’ll be rewarded and if they don’t they’ll be punished. Justice: people get what they deserve. Look at how he reacted to the Israelites in our first reading today: seeing that they built an idol out of gold to worship, his first reaction is to send down his wrath of fire to destroy them. Harsh? Maybe. But he gave them rules to follow, told them that death was the penalty for sin, and they couldn’t even handle the FIRST commandment. Justice meant paying them what they were due, and they were due punishment.
But God didn’t end up doing that, did He? While our God is a God of justice, He is also a God of mercy. Even though He was very clear of the rules, and even though they immediately broken a really big one, God chose to show mercy to His people and give them more than they deserved: a second chance, new life, safety from death.
It’s the same story with St. Paul in our second reading. While we all know Paul as the great missionary that built up the Church after Jesus, sometimes we forget that he was a great sinner prior to his vision of Jesus. In our second reading today he even says himself, “I was once a blasphemer and a persecutor and arrogant, but I have been mercifully treated.” Even though he tore down the church, imprisoned and killed Christians, and denounced Jesus, God did not give him the punishment he was due, He gave him mercy… He gave him forgiveness; God was able to transform something terrible into something great.
Why? Because God loves those who love Him and are perfect, right? God loves those who help themselves, right? Quite the opposite, actually. Time and time again we hear that God loves the outcast… the sinner… the weak… the lowly. The very reason that Jesus tells the parables in our Gospel today is because the Pharisees were complaining about who He was eating with: “This man welcomes tax collectors and sinners and eats with them!” He was eating with the lowest, most detestable people in society. But why? Because no one outside of God’s mercy, there is no length that God won’t go to bring them back.
Jesus asks them, “Who among you, losing one sheep, wouldn’t leave the 99 behind to find the one?” The correct answer is everyone! The idea of leaving behind 99 sheep to find just one is ridiculous! But that’s what God does for all of us. He’s like the woman who completely overturned the whole house to find just one coin and threw a major party over it. He’s like the father who didn’t care that his son disrespected him, took half of his wealth, defaced himself, and then came crawling back for help. No one is outside of God’s mercy… no matter who they are… no matter what they’ve done.
God doesn’t treat us fairly, He doesn’t give us what we’re due… he gives us so much more than we deserve. Even tax collectors. Even sinners. Even people who lie and cheat and say mean things to their parents, who don’t feel connected at mass, or don’t even think they need God. Even them, you, and me. Even… Even terrorists.
On this the 15th anniversary of the September 11th attacks on our country, we will be inundated with a simple, two-word message: Never forget… Never forget… Never forget. It’s a powerful message, a catchy message, an important message. But what does it mean? What exactly is it that we never want to forget as long as we live?
For some, it is an opportunity to focus on justice. What we should never forget is the horror of the day: the deaths of so many people and the hatred of the people that did it to us. This was an objectively evil act, and we need to take it upon ourselves to give them what they’re due: punishment. Never forget what they did.
When we go down this road, fueled by hate and anger and fear, we have a tendency to take horrible, sinful acts and give them back even worse. More than 300,000 middle-Easterners dead, torture, regular acts of distrust, name-calling, and violence against completely innocent Muslim citizens of this country. If all we remember is the terrible acts of the day, if all we remember is the sadness and anger we felt when it happened, that is likely all we are going to be able to give back in return.
Is that the Christian response?
In light of our readings today, I want to suggest an alternative, that the thing we should “Never Forget” is not the evil of that day… but rather the mercy of God who continues to be with us all… even the sinners. The God who turns evil into good and never tires of chasing after us…even the terrorists. The God who doesn’t give us what we deserve, because he gives us so much more. Instead of remembering the deaths of so many, let’s never forget the lives that God touched, the saints and sinners in those buildings for whom God waited on patiently their whole lives. Instead of remembering the destruction and turmoil, let’s never forget the heroic acts of first responders risking their lives for others, how the whole city, an entire nation united together, moving beyond our differences to be one. Instead of remembering the terrible things that others have done and how they need justice, let’s never forget that we are all sinners and yet all of us have been treated mercifully by God.
When people hurt us, they betray our trust, inflict pain… our first reaction is almost always to get even; we want justice. And there’s room for that: a world in which no one is accountable for there actions and sin is okay is not a world that our God wants. But we never need reminding of this; our instinct to fix this comes naturally. What we do need from time to time, though, what we must never forget, is that God has treated with his mercy, and wants us to do the same for others. Never forget.
For those receiving this post by email, click here for the short video reflection related to this post.
Thanks, Br. Casey. On the 15th anniversary of 9/11, it’s a needed homily for all if us. Mary McCarthy, Greenville
Hi Brother Casey!
Your writing is impressive and your thoughts and words are so incredibly important today. I love reading your blog. Always choose love…
Fr. Mychal Fallon Judge, O.F.M., FDNY Chaplain – R.I.P. 9/11/2001.
and all the many hundreds of others who lived out John 15: 13 that day.
Hi Bro. Casey…
Thank you for your deep and penetrating thoughts re: 9/11. Like a phoenix rising out of the ashes, so has the spirit of the American people…never forget and never give up.
Watched your “Never Forget” video and it is apparent that you just don’t get it. Even though I am a “sinner” as you say we all are, I never stole airplanes, used them to crash into commercial towers thus killing the people on board, I never caused the death of over 3000 people in those buildings, caused them to be burned alive, jumping for their lives from those buildings and leaving all types of family members without mother, father, brother, sister and the list goes on, causing the deaths of the first responders and even to this day having them die due to the cancers they got fighting this tragedy which adds to the 3000 death count. Need I go any further. I expect you are smart enough to get the picture.
Maybe when you are old enough, you will understand. Your speech about the hate – that will burn forever every time September 11 comes around. Just look what happen with the incidents in Minnesota and New Jersey. America won’t stand for the “cookies and cream” love solution you propose. Think about it.
I’m so thankful you watched and commented. You’re right: you did not do any of those things. And I hope you don’t think I said that. But what so many of us HAVE done (and still do) is let that anger and sadness control us for 15 years. We’ve let what someone else did hurt us long after the rubble was cleared. Many people still live with tremendous resentment and hate.
But I don’t get what “Cookies and cream” mean. I’m a Christian and I think I’m not alone in thinking that killing 10 people for every one of ours that died is not justice, it’s manic rage. I wonder how many people in Iraq and Afghanistan now feel exactly as you do now… I wonder how many have lived through bombs and flames and deaths and funerals and hate over the past 15 years.
I may not agree with your opinion, but I definitely “get it.” As Christians, we cannot support torture, mass killings, or abuse of Muslims. There is never an excuse.
Pingback: On Sept. 11 Anniversary, Communities Pray for Peace – St. Joseph Catholic Church & School in Anderson SC | (864) 225-5341