Documentaries: Just the Facts, Part of the Truth

Click here to listen

I have a friend that only reads non-fiction. He likes biographies, news articles, and reports published in academic journals. Why waste time, he wonders, with things that are not real, with stories that are made up? For him, one should just stick to the facts.

Naturally, I don’t agree with him. Quite obviously, given our previous episodes of this podcast, I find that fiction can actually capture truth in ways that non-fiction cannot, helping us to enter into a reality far from our own to learn something new about ourselves and others. But I think it’s more than that. Not only can fiction capture the truth, but there is a misconception about non-fiction that just because it is “factual” that it is without bias or subjectivity. This is patently false.

Unfortunately, many viewers/readers of non-fiction tend to approach these works of art without a critical eye; they tend to accept what is shown as the truth without reflection because, well, it’s “non-fiction.” In documentaries, for example, one is able to see with their own eyes the primary sources. They can watch the actual events, hear the actual historical figure speak. It must be true, we tell ourselves.

The fact of the matter is that works of non-fiction and fiction—while using opposite approaches—essentially seek to do the same thing: they tell stories to transmit truth. They choose what to be included and what to leave out. They build story arcs, build drama, make arguments, and seek to evoke a response from the viewer/reader. Works of non-fiction may use nothing but factual pieces of information, but in choosing what to present, and more importantly, what to leave out, they inevitably share a truth that is incomplete. No one is able to share everything about every situation that influenced the topic at hand.

That’s where things get interesting, and what Br. Tito and I discussed in this week’s podcast. How do documentaries reveal much-needed truth, but how do they also leave us with more questions than answers?

One Comment on “Documentaries: Just the Facts, Part of the Truth

  1. Just listened to the Fyre documentary after hearing about it on your podcast. It was interesting but i was absolutely apalled by its courseness, profanity, and crudities. I guess that is how the “culture” often comports itself these days but that two catholic friars can watch this without even a passing comment to its crassiness makes me wonder (and fret a bit) of how deeply ingrained some of this junk now is. I think the world of so much of your content but this as well as other nuetral-to-positive observations you have on some really profane and obnoxious entertainment from the culture makes me wonder if you as catholic men of faith might not be be be a bit to comfortable with the dark underbelly of modern entertainment. In our faith, should we be giving this junk any of our support or should we be calling it out as being less of what the Lord would want from his creations?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: